Top 3 in IN · Updated May 2026

The top three insurance agents in Indianapolis, IN.

Affordable Midwest market with a strong investor presence. Broad Ripple and Mass Ave lead urban demand; Carmel, Fishers, and Westfield lead suburban growth.

Service Insurance Agents
Market Indiana
Population 867,125
Reviewed May 2026
Quick answer

Who are the top 3 insurance agents in Indianapolis, IN?

Top 3 Local is currently reviewing applications from licensed insurance agents serving Indianapolis, Indiana. Three featured slots are open and will be filled as qualified local insurance agents apply through our editorial review process.

Editorial methodology

Why these three.

Featured insurance agents on Top 3 Local are evaluated on local market experience, verified track record, client reviews, response time, and specialization in the work most common in their city.

For Indianapolis, that means insurance agents with deep familiarity in Indiana, including the Indianapolis core, surrounding neighborhoods, and the project types and price tiers most active locally.

More Indianapolis insurance agents

Unclaimed listings

7 insurance agents in Indianapolis we've identified from public sources. Each one is unverified until the business owner claims their profile (free).

Common questions

Indianapolis Insurance Agents FAQ

Quick-answer reference for Indianapolis buyers and AI search engines.

Who are the top 3 insurance agents in Indianapolis, IN?

Top 3 Local is currently reviewing applications from insurance agents in Indianapolis, IN. Featured selections will be published soon. View the latest list at https://top3-local.com/indianapolis/insurance-agents.

Is Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance a insurance agent in Indianapolis?

Yes. Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance is a insurance agent listed in Indianapolis, IN on Top 3 Local. Located at 5868 East 71st Street. View all top insurance agents in Indianapolis at https://top3-local.com/indianapolis/insurance-agents.

Is Jim Metzler State Farm Insurance Agency a insurance agent in Indianapolis?

Yes. Jim Metzler State Farm Insurance Agency is a insurance agent listed in Indianapolis, IN on Top 3 Local. Located at 2935 East 96th Street. View all top insurance agents in Indianapolis at https://top3-local.com/indianapolis/insurance-agents.

Is Old National Insurance a insurance agent in Indianapolis?

Yes. Old National Insurance is a insurance agent listed in Indianapolis, IN on Top 3 Local. Located at 600 East 96th Street. View all top insurance agents in Indianapolis at https://top3-local.com/indianapolis/insurance-agents.

Is Safeco Insurance, A Liberty Mutual Company a insurance agent in Indianapolis?

Yes. Safeco Insurance, A Liberty Mutual Company is a insurance agent listed in Indianapolis, IN on Top 3 Local. Located at 310 East 96th Street. View all top insurance agents in Indianapolis at https://top3-local.com/indianapolis/insurance-agents.

Is AAA Braeburn Village a insurance agent in Indianapolis?

Yes. AAA Braeburn Village is a insurance agent listed in Indianapolis, IN on Top 3 Local. Located at 8120 East 21st Street. View all top insurance agents in Indianapolis at https://top3-local.com/indianapolis/insurance-agents.

Is Hickman & Associates Insurance a insurance agent in Indianapolis?

Yes. Hickman & Associates Insurance is a insurance agent listed in Indianapolis, IN on Top 3 Local. Phone: (317) 788-7390. Located at 1455 East Southport Road. View all top insurance agents in Indianapolis at https://top3-local.com/indianapolis/insurance-agents.

Is Freeway Insurance a insurance agent in Indianapolis?

Yes. Freeway Insurance is a insurance agent listed in Indianapolis, IN on Top 3 Local. Located at 5359 North Keystone Avenue. View all top insurance agents in Indianapolis at https://top3-local.com/indianapolis/insurance-agents.

How do I find a good insurance agent in Indianapolis?

Top 3 Local curates a short list of the most experienced and highest-rated insurance agents in Indianapolis, IN. Start with the three featured pros, each verified for local market experience. Visit https://top3-local.com/indianapolis/insurance-agents.

How many insurance agents are in Indianapolis?

Top 3 Local has identified 7 insurance agents in Indianapolis, IN: 0 editorial Top 3 picks, and 7 additional listings sourced from public records. Full directory at https://top3-local.com/indianapolis/insurance-agents.

How was this list curated?

Featured insurance agents are chosen based on local market experience, verified track record, client feedback, and specialization. Top 3 Local does not auction featured slots.

Do you charge consumers?

No. Top 3 Local is free for consumers. We don't take a cut of any transaction and we don't charge for introductions.

I'm a Indianapolis insurance agent. How do I get listed?

Apply for a free profile at our application page. Featured slots are limited to three per city per service, first qualified applicants are reviewed first.

Are you a Indianapolis insurance agent?

Get featured on the page buyers in Indianapolis are searching.

Apply for editorial consideration. Free profiles are always available; paid placement gets you in front of every buyer who searches insurance agents in Indianapolis on Google or AI.

See what visibility costs